Please be sure you're signed in to your Pantastic account. When signed in your name should be visible in the top right corner of the screen.
If you still do not see the rewards slider when checking out, you may have a default setting to use Shop Pay. When you have been directed to the Shop Pay checkout screen, click "Check Out as Guest" and you will be returned to the regular checkout screen with the slider.
Please remember that your Indie Insider Rewards cannot be redeemed in conjunction with a discount or promo code.
You may also find this article helpful.